![]() |
Legal News UPDATE: Court Stays Order Compelling Production of Quality Reviews, Allowing Appellate Review of Peer Review Protection ActLast month, In his opinion granting the stay of his August 2014 order, Judge Nealon conceded that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court case on which he based his decision—McClellan v. Health Maintenance Organization of PA—was a plurality opinion and therefore has no precedential value, as Blue Cross and First Priority argued. Accordingly, Judge Nealon stated in his most recent order that there was no appellate review of the issue whether the PRPA encompasses peer reviews conducted by hospital plan corporations. With no appellate review, Judge Nealon found that the moving defendants possessed the requisite substantial ground for difference of opinion necessary for an appeal to the Superior Court. Despite the imminent appeal, Judge Nealon anticipated that the case is at least nine months away from trial in Lackawanna County and the issue should be decided to avoid irreparable harm that may result from prematurely exposing the reviews before their discoverable nature was defined. |
Hickory Pointe 2250 Hickory Rd, Suite 300 Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462 Phone: (610) 834-8800 Fax: (610) 834-1749 info@obrlaw.com |