by Joe Quirk | Nov 20, 2026 | Hospital Liability, Medical Malpractice, Philadelphia, Successes
Carolyn M. Bohmueller and Heather J. Hulit obtained a defense verdict on behalf of an anesthesiologist and hospital in the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas. The matter involved a 47-year patient who underwent a seven-hour jaw advancement surgery to expand his airway and treat his severe obstructive sleep apnea. All prior treatments – CPAP machine and nasal surgery – had failed. The patient was intubated through the nasal passage to avoid the surgical field. Anesthesia was carefully managed and carried out throughout the lengthy procedure. Once the procedure was completed, the patient’s jaw was wired shut and the anesthesia team began the process of awakening the patient. The patient passed all extubation criteria, the nasotracheal tube was removed and almost immediately he went into respiratory distress, triggering cardiac arrest. Immediately bag-masking was initiated, a code blue was called, CPR was started, the wires holding his jaws together were cut, and he was emergently reintubated within 3-4 minutes. However, after reintubation, his EtCO2 levels remained low, indicating hypoxemia, and he required continued CPR and cardioversion to retain pulses. The patient was sedated and treated with cooling therapy to reduce brain damage from the hypoxia and remained sedated on and the ventilator for another 12 days. The patient was successfully weaned off the ventilator and discharged to inpatient rehab.
At trial, plaintiffs presented an anesthesiology expert who asserted that if the anesthesiologist-defendant had used a tube exchanger via the nasal passageway, the patient could have been reintubated faster and the injury would have been prevented. Additionally, he presented experts who claimed that his injuries from this event were so severe that he was unable to work or provide services/assistance to his wife and children. The defense effectively established that the anesthesia team acted expeditiously, efficiently and their plan was the standard of care. The defense anesthesia expert outlined all of the steps taken by the anesthesia team to reduce the risk of injury to the patient; why use of a tube exchanger would have increased, not decreased the risk of harm; and that this injury would not have been prevented by any different course of action by the anesthesiologist. After an eight day trial and several hours of deliberation the jury returned a verdict finding that the anesthesiologist was not negligent.
by Joe Quirk | Apr 23, 2026 | Medical Malpractice, Philadelphia, Successes
Mary Kay Plyter-Eigner and Emily A. Giradi obtained a defense verdict on behalf of a urology group in the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas. The matter involved a patient who was diagnosed with adenocarcinoma of the prostate following a biopsy. The urologist recommended active surveillance but additionally counseled the patient that a radical prostatectomy would be a reasonable treatment option given the patient’s young age. After monitoring the patient’s prostate cancer for approximately six months, an MRI and repeat biopsy revealed that the cancer had progressed to an intermediate grade for which active surveillance was no longer a good option. The urologist recommended surgical treatment to which the patient agreed.
The patient underwent a laparoscopic radical prostatectomy, bilateral lymph node dissection, lysis of adhesions, and cystoscopy with no noted complications. At the conclusion of the procedure, the urologist inspected the entirety of the bowel and found no perforations. There were several locations with serosal tears which were reapproximated using interrupted 3-0 Vicryl.
Following the surgery, the patient experienced persistent abdominal pain. The Plaintiff alleged that the robotic assisted laparoscopic prostatectomy was improperly performed resulting in a bowel perforation. Plaintiff further alleged that Defendants failed to promptly diagnose and treat the bowel perforation, resulting in the need for multiple corrective surgeries. The defense argued that the urologist properly and carefully performed the surgery. Prior to placement of the necessary trocars, Plaintiff had numerous adhesions that required removal and lysis through a tedious process. Several serosal tears were noted and repaired. The bowel was inspected at the beginning, middle, and end of the case with no perforation noted.
After deliberating, the jury returned a verdict in favor of the urologist and urology group, finding that their care and treatment of the patient was not negligent.
by Joe Quirk | Nov 4, 2024 | Medical Malpractice, Philadelphia, Successes
Tracie A. Vizza and associate, Sarah Holtzhauer, obtained a defense verdict in Philadelphia County in a case where it was alleged that a podiatrist failed to appropriately appreciate symptoms of a neurological issue and failed to refer the patient to a neurologist.
The patient had seen the foot and ankle surgeon on two occasions, over a three month period and it was contested as to what complaints were made at each visit. Although the patient testified that she complained of radiating numbness and pain down her legs to her feet at each visit, the physician testified that she only first made those complaints at the second visit. The patient argued that the physician never recommended nor referred her to a neurologist for a
comprehensive work up at either visit. However, the surgeon noted multiple times in the chart and testified convincingly that he had directed the patient to see a neurologist, advising that her complaints appeared to have a neurological cause. Despite the patient’s claims, she did obtain a
neurology consult the following month after the second visit with the podiatrist, but failed to see the neurologist for several months thereafter. The patient was ultimately diagnosed with a spinal AVM and required several spinal procedures.
The jury found in favor of the podiatrist.
by Joe Quirk | Sep 25, 2023 | Medical Malpractice, Philadelphia, Successes
Carolyn M. Bohmueller and Joana Gaizelyte-Lacy represented a maternal fetal medicine specialist in a four-day trial in Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, and secured a defense verdict. The claim involved the stillbirth of fetus at 36 weeks gestation. The fetus had a single umbilical artery diagnosed at 20 weeks gestation and was closely monitored. At 35 weeks gestation the fetus was diagnosed with intrauterine growth restriction. After ultrasound evaluation and doppler studies along with a non-stress test, a plan was in place to see the patient twice weekly for non-stress tests and undergo doppler studies and amniotic fluid evaluation weekly. At the first non-stress test the patient alleged she complained of decreased fetal movement. A non-stress test performed that day was reassuring and reactive. At the following scheduled visit three days later, a fetal demise was diagnosed. The jury deliberated and quickly returned a verdict in favor of the maternal fetal specialist, finding he was not negligent.
by Joe Quirk | Sep 25, 2023 | Medical Malpractice, Philadelphia, Successes
Attorneys Carolyn M. Bohmueller and Jamie N. Johnson secured a verdict in favor of two emergency room physicians and a hospital in a two-week trial in Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas involving a claim of failure to diagnose recurrence of breast cancer. The patient had been diagnosed with breast cancer at age 23 and underwent surgical and adjuvant therapy. She continued to follow with her oncologist. Fourteen years later, she presented to a local emergency department with complaints of left-sided chest pain, which were evaluated and determined to be non-specific, and she was instructed to follow up with her providers. The following year, she presented again to the emergency department with a complaint of pain in her head behind her right ear, which was evaluated and she was instructed to follow up with her primary care physician. Over two years later, the patient was diagnosed with widely metastatic recurrent breast cancer in her lungs, pelvis and brain. The jury determined that neither of the emergency room physicians, nor the hospital, were negligent.
by Mark Bauman | Apr 21, 2022 | Medical Malpractice, Philadelphia, Successes
Attorneys Michael Pitt and Mary Kay Plyter-Eigner recently received a defense verdict on behalf of a gastroenterologist and his practice after a three week trial in Philadelphia County. Plaintiff, on behalf of her deceased husband, alleged that the Defendant gastroenterologist failed to appropriately perform a gastroscope and recommend surgical intervention in a patient with signs of gastrointestinal bleeding. After 20 days of evidence, including testimony from more than ten medical experts, the defendants, and multiple fact witnesses, the jury returned a verdict about four hours later finding in favor of the defense gastroenterologist.